top of page

Employee Benefits

A 33% Decrease to Health Insurance Spend in 3 Years

Published on
Written by:
Page View
April 15, 2022
Cottingham & Butler

A county in northeastern Wisconsin was facing a 6% increase in their health insurance costs.

Line graph indicating the anonymized client's total health insurance cost. A notable decrease is seen when Cottingham & Butler is noted as the named Broker of Record.

Cottingham & Butler's public sector team was invited to conduct our 3C's analysis, where we benchmark coverage, cost, and consumption compared to peer counties and municipalities in the area. This analysis leads to identifying areas for opportunity and allows us to make targeted quantifiable recommendations.


Pharmacy Contract Review

We renegotiated the pharmacy benefit manager contract, moving from a 3-year to a 1-year contract. We also introduced step-therapy and coupon tracking on medications that led to $115k in savings.


Tenure-Based Opt Out

We implemented a $5,000 cash opt-out based on tenure. This was an added benefit offered to employees with over 20 years of service to the County that led to over $84k in savings.


High-Performance Network

We recommended that the County introduce a tiered high-performance network, incenting members (but not mandating them) to use high-quality, low-cost providers leading to over $280k in savings.


An anonymous quote from Cottingham & Butler's public sector client, which outlines their positive experience with C&B's Employee Benefits team.

View All Posts
TAGS:

Upcoming Events

WEBINAR

November 10, 2025

Safety Reimagined: Setting Goals That Actually Drive Change

Join SMSC Safety Consultant Scott Christenson for an engaging webinar that explores how to set safety goals that go beyond compliance and transform organizational culture by applying Human and Organizational Performance (HOP) principles. Participants will learn how to shift from traditional metrics to goals that foster continuous learning, organizational resilience, and worker empowerment.
Register Now!
Register Now!

WEBINAR

December 18, 2025

Year-in-Review & Looking Ahead

Throughout 2025, HR and employee benefits professionals have continued to navigate an evolving compliance landscape for health and welfare benefit plans. As the year draws to a close, this session will highlight the most significant compliance developments and regulatory changes that shaped 2025 and what they mean for your organization. We’ll also look ahead to 2026, previewing upcoming rules, deadlines, and trends that could impact your benefit strategies in the year to come. Whether you're wrapping up year-end compliance or planning for what’s next, this webinar will help you stay informed and prepared. Examples will be provided to help employers manage different types of common employee positions.
Register Now!
Register Now!

WEBINAR

November 20, 2025

HRA Types & Comparisons

With many different permitted types of Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs), employers have a wide array of options to provide tax-favored reimbursement for qualifying medical expenses to employees and their family members. But each HRA type has its own compliance requirements, eligibility rules, and strategic use cases. This month’s webinar will discuss many different HRA types, including HRAs integrated with group medical plans, excepted benefit HRAs, qualified small employer HRAs, individual coverage HRAs, and retiree-only HRAs. We’ll explore how each type works, when it might be a good fit, and what employers need to know to stay compliant.
Register Now!
Register Now!
View All Events

Connect with a C&B Representative Today!

bottom of page