At Cottingham & Butler, we believe every challenge has a solution. Explore how we partner with clients to create breakthrough solutions that deliver meaningful, measurable impact.
When ag retail hit a rough patch with carriers pulling out, coverage gaps at the worst possible time, Jamal Khali and his team at Farmers Co-op Association & Vision Ag needed more than a policy. They needed a partner.
Chicago manufacturer slashes 52% renewal increase to just 4.7%, avoiding $323K in premiums and removing $1.5M+ in claims through strategic benefit solutions.
For Brite Logistics, joining a captive took multiple years of diligent work. The results speak for themselves. Before partnering with Cottingham & Butler, Brite was in the general market, where the relationship felt purely transactional. Every claim or incident meant going to a different adjuster, making it hard to stay on top of issues from start to finish. That changed when Brite joined the Pursuit captive. What changed: One point of contact for every claim — instead of bou
This transportation company achieves 20% auto liability reduction, doubles cargo limits, and gains captive insurance access in 30 days with Cottingham & Butler's strategic approach.
Discover how Mockingbird Transport saved $150K+ annually through captive insurance. A trucking case study on persistence, peer validation, and strategic partnership.
44% Premium
Reduction Secured
From the Incumbent Carrier
$600,000+ in Annual
Premium Savings
3 of 4 Carrier
DeclinationsOverturned
Creating Real Market Competition
The Situation
A national leader in renewable energy infrastructure and community solar projects came to Cottingham & Butler ahead of a renewal they expected to be expensive and frustrating.
